A lot has already been said about how exceptional this film is, and what a wonderful job J.J. Abrams did to recreate Roddenberry’s original vision. I couldn’t agree more with all the praise – it’s the best movie I’ve seen this year thus far. Therefore, I won’t drone on reiterating all of its fine attributes, but rather want to highlight the three most significant things I walked away with after watching the film:

1) Star Trek has an exceptionally conceived and executed retro style yet is completely contemporary. The feel of the film evoked through the costumes, make-up & styling, set designs, and cinematography is perfectly balanced with all the innovative big-studio bells and whistles afforded to blockbuster action films. Moreover, Star Trek’s designers realize that we’ve become so indoctrinated with the typical sci-fi space-suit garb that the classic wardrobe’s simplicity is much more satisfying and refreshing. The ensemble cast helped reinforce the retro feel with fantastic performances. Without ever resorting to parody, each actor is able to capture the distinct mannerisms and idiosyncrasies of the original cast. It feels more so like they are paying homage rather than poking fun. Matt Damon originally turned down the roll of Kirk, and I’m glad he did. Pine’s smooth arrogance and self-absorption is a wonderful nod to Shatner … (The same praise can be handed to any of the actors – I thought Urban’s ‘Bones’ was also exceptional).
2) So is this a flawless movie? My one big hang-up with the story regards the return of Leonard Nimoy as the original ‘Spock.’ I have absolutely no problem with his initial encounter with Kirk and Scotty on the desolate planet in order to set in motion our hero’s task. In fact, I teared up a bit after Spock instructs Kirk what to do to his younger version, to trust in their friendship, and then says good-bye. Heck, I figured that’s the last I’d likely ever see of Nimoy in that role. But then they violated the wonderful moment they created by bringing Spock into contact with Spock. I have no idea what this accomplished other than to take away from some pretty well established mystique, and interrupt a perfectly flowing narrative with unwanted sentimentality. I did not tear up the second time around … Only real flaw for me. It has nothing to do with the overarching story, which is kind of why it pisses me off. 
3) The most startling realization I had when leaving Star Trek was how boring and forgettable the villain is, and ultimately, how making the villain forgettable is a brilliant strategy for setting up an epic series. The reason Star Trek works so well is because it is a finely crafted and narrowly focused ensemble piece. The filmmakers do not want to confuse us with an epically interesting villain when all of our attention should be focused on the relationships formulating amongst the burgeoning crew of the USS Enterprise. The villain functions just enough to create the time disruption that will propel the rest of the series forward, without having to be faithful to anyone else’s prior work (an ingenious narrative strategy). Notice how Klingons are never even mentioned? … First film sets up our heroes, the second will be all about the villain.

2 comments:
Despite my undisputed status as a lifelong Trek nerd, I didn't really get excited for this until the reviews started coming in so strong.
I mean, I was intrigued by the Director and Producers of LOST taking this on, but it just seemed like such a bad idea to try and recast Shatner and the rest.
I couldn't believe how well the movie worked! It really was the best Trek film they've made, and joins what I'd consider the Holy Trinity of Successful Reboots: Batman, James Bond and now Trek.
All three took well-trodden material that had become a joke and declared dead, and all three benefited from the fact that a complete origin story had never been established (though obviously the most was known about Batman going in) that allowed them to give old characters new depth.
Almost everything in the movie worked for me. Almost.
Nimoy, who's never been a knock-your-socks-off actor but has a certain charm, seemed a bit creaky to me. Pretty much on par with Harrison Ford in The Crystal Skull (though, ironically, Ford was the BEST thing about that movie). You've gotta wonder if JJ Abrams didn't feel comfortable saying, 'Gee, Leonard, don't you think Spock should have a little more subtle charm?'
But if I had to pick one complaint from the movie - and it's certainly not a deal-breaker by any stretch - it's the script's over-reliance on coincidences to work.
Nero shows up at Kirk's birth and completely changes his life.
Kirk runs into everyone from the Enterprise anyway.
He's shot off onto a frozen planet (moon?) - the weakest plot turn in the movie - and lands in THE EXACT SAME PLACE as Spock.
Oh, and they happen to be a couple miles away from Scotty.
It smacks a lot of 'fate' and how they were all 'meant to be' together.
Now, LOST is famously reliant on coincidences, but it's an overt narrative device on a show that's completely obsessed with questions of fate, destiny, free will, etc.
Ultimately, I'm chalking it up to a movie having as much fun as it can, so we're to see the coincidences as funny nudge-nudge moments.
But it is a bit ironic as the first two Star Trek series were very, very secular (Roddenberry was an avowed atheist) and usually only fell back on coincidence when writers found themselves in a corner rather than trying to make any sort of statement.
(Actually, Deep Space Nine brilliantly played with notions of science, faith, moral dilemmas, war and terrorism, and I still think it's the best Trek, but it's a long way from Kirk and Co.)
I suppose I'm coming off negative, so I should add again that I LOVED the movie and I'm very much looking forward to the next one.
Post a Comment