Showing posts with label Bonnie Burton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bonnie Burton. Show all posts

Saturday, July 30, 2011

"Oh You Sexy Paradox"

One of the more interesting panels from last week's Comic Con was one that I could not attend because I was presenting at the exact same time. The panel I missed was called "Oh You Sexy Geek" and focused on the growing presence of "geek girls" in popular culture and related issues regarding sexuality, objectification, and power. The panelists (Bonnie Burton, Adrienne Curry, Clare Grant, Jill Pantozzi, Clare Kramer, Kiala Kazebee, and Jennifer Stuller) were asked questions about 'fangirls' displaying sexiness, and whether the blending of sex-appeal and nerdiness liberates women or panders to male fantasies. Katrina Hill from ActionChickFlick.com moderated the panel, which has since sparked a bit of Internet buzz with critics who have offered a variety of opinions: the good, the bad, and the ugly. In reading several of these reviews, there seems to be a lack of consensus regarding what the panel actually achieved. At the very least, it seems as though they opened the door to many pertinent issues on the topic, which perhaps could use additional framing. As such, the following is intended to add to a discussion that I completely missed out on. I nonetheless have some thoughts on the tensions that arise because of this issue, and thought I would offer them here. I apologize if what I have to say is redundant, or if I make sweeping assumptions about what was said (or more likely, what was not said) on the panel.

In order to have this discussion, I think it's a good idea to remember a couple key attributes regarding who we are in relation to popular culture. First, we are largely talking about representations of women in popular culture, which we take to have (at least some) influence on how we socialize and live/perform our "real" identity outside what we consume on TV and in comic books. Because society (and the entertainment industry) is largely constructed and controlled by men, we end up with masculine filters through which all representations in popular entertainment are projected. This is amplified even more so in science fiction and superhero genres wherein the very perception of what it means to be a hero is cast through male adolescent fantasies (i.e. Siegel and Shuster) of what a couple nerdy kids wish they could have (strength, courage, wisdom, a hot girlfriend). In other words, comic books and sci-fi/action flicks not only say something about the current state of the human condition, but also depict (through a masculine filter) a fantasy of what someday might be. Of course, these dominant projections within the genre have historically cast women as subservient, overtly sexual, and physically/intellectually inferior.

This is an important distinction to make when we place this topic in a scenario like Comic Con and fandom, wherein the body is not only on display, but is also expected to be displayed in fantastical and evocative ways. Thus, we are talking about representations of the ideal female body as opposed to any 'accurate' or 'authentic' representation of the human form. The same holds true when depicting male super-bodies, however, the costumed female body (both in comics and at the Con) feature much more skin. Whereas masculine bodies are likely to be hidden under a costume, the female (Utopian) body is made bare and reveals flesh in spite of the costume.

In fulfilling these dominant fantasies, female characters in comics/sci-fi exist as a tension between two aspects of (masculine) desire: namely, the heroine and the whore. Women are expected to fulfill the role of the super-heroine, but also be abjectly appetizing or sexually naughty while doing it. Take Catwoman for example. She is a paradoxical character because she is both good and bad, sinner and saint, subservient and independent. Though she will ally herself with Batman in combat and in bed, she nonetheless resists the social morality and institutional laws handed down by men/patriarchy. Read this way, Catwoman could seemingly be a very strong female character to emulate, if she weren't also dressed like a dominatrix. As fashionable as leather, whips, and stilettos may be, they are more evocative of bondage taboos than the functional attire of what a cat burglar might wear.

Now, the question becomes, does a similar paradox exist for geek girls? 'Nerds' and 'Geeks' by definition are not sexy. But if you're a woman who seeks to have presence within this community (online, in print, or at Comic Con), is it also a prerequisite that you be sexy? Will fanboys/girls read your work if you're not? Perhaps there are no concrete answers to these questions, but rather it is better to question our own complicity in playing out (or reifying) these tensions. I find it troublesome that half the panelists for "Oh You Sexy Geek" had a hard time taking the topic seriously, followed by the sole male participant (Chris Gore) meandering in an hour late to offer lewd sexual comments ("jokes") that served no purpose beyond exerting and amplifying the very paradox I just laid out ... Again, post-coverage of the panel is confusing. Another male blogger offered luke-warm praise, but only after he clearly states at the outset that he normally would never attend such a panel but was trying to save a seat for the fantasy stuff slated to follow. Many female bloggers covering the panel note how funny everyone was and that the room was filled to capacity, but little as far as where this issue leaves us ... I don't know, I wasn't there. Was this a successful panel?

On a positive note, the growing presence of "geek girls" and women at Comic Con in general is a very good thing. As Seth Green noted, there is a sincerity of inclusion that clearly exists within all of the contributors (well, maybe not Gore). Again, my point here is not to place blame on the problems of representation, but point to areas of contention where geek girl tensions play out, and theorize where they potentially come from. As much as we tend to bind ourselves to popular depictions and representations of gender and sexuality, we can also use performance and costuming to resist or criticize them. Vicki Callahan offers us a reminder of how within these tensions also exist room for emancipation ...


It is easy to criticize this behavior as sexist, especially given the presence of super-heroine porn on the Internet, much of which plays out elaborate rape fantasies. Yet, there is a sense in which these women at the Comic Con occupy a position of power. The characters they poach and embody are often figures of strength; you will see many women dressed as 'bad-ass' characters such as Wonder Woman or Jean Grey and none dressed as Lois Lane or Mary Jane Parker.


Finally, "Oh You Sexy Geek" framed their panel by asking about the abundance and popularity of "Slave Leia." During the panel, Bonnie Burton attempted to give reverence to the iconic costume/character by reminding us that Princess Leia was able to kill Jabba the Hut because of her particular outfit, and asks What could be more empowering than that? ... I feel that Leia is most empowered if we see her as symbolically choking the life out of the blubbery fanboy who has her enslaved as a sexual object. However, at Comic Con, I think it is still more likely that the geek girls who dress as Slave Leia seek to display their sexuality for the gratification of the gaze, rather than celebrating the suffocation of patriarchy as the life drains out of Jabba's twitching phallic tail.

I'm glad to know more and more geek girls, and hope within these pop discourses we can find a better balance and equality regarding presence and representation. The geek girl movement is a great start; we've got a long way to go ...