Others have come forward to defend Oswalt, aptly pointing out that should the fan’s video make its way to Youtube, any residual value of his work being “new material” would be forever lost in the age of viral communication. Again, Oswalt was at the venue to test the material on an unexpecting audience (pretty much the only way a comedian can tell if their stuff works or needs re-tweaking). In fact, Oswalt most assuredly stakes his livelihood on being able to strategically release and sell his ‘product’ to the right people, at the right time. But for this performance, he certainly had no intention of releasing the material to the world.
While reading her post as well as some of the fall-out on Twitter, I was very much reminded of how this tension plays itself out in my own profession; in the college classroom. Within the first week of a new class students will inevitably ask me if they can record my lectures or if I will e-mail/post my notes for them online. Much to their chagrin, I always tell them that I will not be doing so. For me, the tension ends up playing out in regard to intellectual property rights. Our ability to quickly and efficiently (re)produce high quality recordings of content is both a blessing and burden for many educators. The knowledge that we have to offer (especially in an area of expertise wherein we’ve spent long hours and many years mastering it) becomes less scarce and infinitely more so out of our control once it is in the public domain. Hypothetically, if an excellent history teacher who focuses on the U.S. Civil War has high quality recordings of his/her lectures or notes reproduced and mass disseminated, is there as much need for the teacher anymore? Can we justify paying them even less since what they have to offer, their unique contribution, is already available (usually for free) at everyone's fingertips?
As educators, we are inclined to give students every opportunity to learn and succeed. Technology is a great way to facilitate learning, however it also comes at a cost that the consumer (students) don’t often recognize or appreciate. Concert goers, comedy fans, and students assume that if they bought a ticket or paid tuition, they are somehow entitled to record, reproduce, or do whatever they like with any of the content they encounter. They think they now own it through their experience of it. Barbara and her supporters call this fandom, and feel that people like Patton Oswalt should interpret such a gesture as praise. However, the fan’s enjoyment potentially comes at the cost of their idol’s livelihood (but even beyond that, do you really need to record something in order to enjoy it?) … Though this fan was quick to comply with Oswalt, many people who record entertainers rather do so to profit off it, either through their own notoriety for having exclusive material, or simply to rip it off. Likewise, some students who request to record my lectures are very genuine in wanting easier access to the most accurate information. However, I am not naive enough not to realize that such requests sometimes translate into Will you post all of your lectures so that I can feel free to zone out in class or not show up altogether?
Regardless, there is a real risk and danger in making your work so easily copied and disseminated. The consequences include outright plagiarism, a loss of property control (as with Oswalt), but also a depreciation of one’s unique contributions, of what it took to come up with the content in the first place. Pablo Picasso was once asked to doodle a sketch on a napkin for a admirer who happened to come across him while eating in a café. Picasso relented and haphazardly scribbled down a doodle on a napkin, signed it, then asked the patron for an exorbitant amount of money. The story goes that the fan was taken aback by the price tag and proclaimed “But it only took you a minute to draw it.” To which Picasso replied, “No, it took me 40 years to learn how to draw this.”
Regarding Oswalt and Gray, the heated exchanges are largely due to how Gray interprets Oswalt’s handling of the situation, which she calls “disrespectful” (as if stand-up comedians are a bastion of genteel courteousness). Oswalt was justified in being defensive (perhaps a little too crass) at the fan who was recording him. I’m sure it’s a common problem for people in his situation, and context is key here. For me, when a student asks if they can record my lecture, I have the luxury to detour my conversation to include an intelligent dialogue about intellectual property rights, and my students tend to see my point of view. With stand-up comedy, however, it would be such a huge buzz kill (and so very annoying) to have to stop a performance every time a fan pulls out their phone and explain the very serious reasons why they need to put it away. The more easy, instinctual, and “funny” way to do it would be ridicule and make fun of the fan, as was the case.
So who is in the wrong here, Oswalt or Gray? I would say neither of them. Oswalt understandably overreacted to the incident, a visceral and aggressive response to a large problem that extends beyond the realm of live comedy. Likewise, Gray understandably overreacted to seeing one of her heroes ‘struggle’ through (and in her eyes, mishandle) a difficult situation ... Hopefully both can understand where each is ultimately coming from and recognize and forgive the misunderstanding for what it is.
Update: Patton Oswalt has since posted his version of what went down.


