The series finale of LOST aired last night after six seasons of the most challenging, thought provoking, and emotionally jarring television we have seen in a while. Staying true to its form, the final episode "The End" is as complex as its predecessors and alludes to as many questions as it attempts to answer ... As such, there is a lot of praise and dissatisfaction being expressed simultaneously about the series. We here at HTM can empathize with those frustrated, but by our indications, the show is very far ahead of its time.LOST is ingenious because it takes us to the threshold of what we know about ourselves. It introduces complex philosophical/scientific theories (even just an allusion can send a fanatic into a research frenzy) and forces us to then think about them in relation to each other, as a complex puzzle, across discontinuous paradigms; and more importantly, as a complex nexus of what we know to be real/true. It accomplishes all this while carefully unpacking the human condition and the emotions we endure when faced with fear, isolation, and a desire to survive. I implore LOST haters to name one show in the history of television that has taken up such a lofty goal!
LOST continuously pits science and faith in opposition. The presence of faith is first articulated through Locke, who trusts the island to tell him what to do. Jack is the embodiment of science, a doctor who makes decisions based on rational problem solving. Throughout the first few seasons we see this tension play out. However, the roles change once Locke die
s, the MIB takes over his body, and Jack begins to question himself. Upon returning to the island with the Oceanic Six, Jack slowly realizes that there are alternatives (to rational explanations) that he can rely on. He becomes more spiritual, reflective, and distant by the end of the series (and Matthew Fox deserves an Emmy nomination for showing the evolution; as do Terry O'Quinn and Michael Emerson). Ultimately, it takes faith for him to reemerge as a leader. Simultaneous to these changes, we seemingly get closer and closer to scientific explanations regarding how the island functions (welcome Daniel Faraday), as well as the relationships that historically (but not necessarily chronologically) bind all of the characters together.
s, the MIB takes over his body, and Jack begins to question himself. Upon returning to the island with the Oceanic Six, Jack slowly realizes that there are alternatives (to rational explanations) that he can rely on. He becomes more spiritual, reflective, and distant by the end of the series (and Matthew Fox deserves an Emmy nomination for showing the evolution; as do Terry O'Quinn and Michael Emerson). Ultimately, it takes faith for him to reemerge as a leader. Simultaneous to these changes, we seemingly get closer and closer to scientific explanations regarding how the island functions (welcome Daniel Faraday), as well as the relationships that historically (but not necessarily chronologically) bind all of the characters together.But then we are given an ending without concrete scientific explanations, and rather end up in a church. When it comes to clarity, I believe LOST's inadequacies in offering "answers" is contingent on the fact that they've already shown us everything they/we seem to know about time travel, metaphysics, parallel existence, God, etc. But they nonetheless still have to finish their story! ... You can criticize LOST for leaning too much on the side of faith, and thereby rendering all the theories that are needed to justify scientific explanations pretty useless. The ending reveals that this entire time we've been dealing with death, and suddenly all the rational/scientific rules don't necessarily apply. 'Drink from the cup' and 'Follow the light' is all we need to know. LOST seems to suggest that try as we might to reconcile faith and science in order to fully understand the central question of the show, "Where are we?", the one thing that we are left with which we can truly rely on is each other, our 'lived' experiences. Once the show has offered us everything else (all the allusions to theory, philosophy, physics, literature, history, etc.) the only thing left to do is finish the story.
The overarching story is essentially about the MIB's desire to get off the island and Jacob's need to keep him there, as well as find a replacement. Exactly why Jacob needs to keep him there is abstractly explained via every parable you can conceive of regarding the nature of good and evil. The origin of the light (as well as good/evil in this sense) is never offered, and like our exact origin, may never be 'known' (perhaps only experienced). But the effects of this conflict run in a multiplicity of directions. Jacob involves the 'survivors' of Oceanic 815 (his 'candidates'). He selects them, sometimes from a very early age, as he seemingly already knows the entirety of their experiences regardless if they've yet to happen. Free will does not seem to exist. But the pilot episode does not start with Jacob and the MIB. LOST is about the people who are affected by things that are out of their control, but what they want to understand and have control over regardless. The story is about us, and therefore, it sequentially unfolds in a manner that privileges our limited experiences as the primary means of 'knowing' (Epic and ingenious storytelling structure).

Jack, in his death and with the power of Jacob (eye closes), seems to transcend the limitations that Jacob saw in all of them. He creates (or there is always the potential to experience) the "sideways" reality in which NONE of the limiting attributes Jacob saw in the candidates any longer exists (Jack's a successful father, Sawyer a moral cop, Ben's a good guy, etc.) ... I think a lot of critics over-rely on the assumption that the sideways reality is purgatory. Rather, if time is discontinuous in death, and experience matters more than the chronology of events, then this "sideways" reality is as much about the characters transcending the destiny set out for them by Jacob's touch ... Another experience (perhaps one of their choosing), before they go on to experience something new?
In their final conversation, Jack's father seems to suggest to him that time, space, and chronology don't matter as much as experience:
Jack: I don't understand. You died.
Dad: Yes, I did.
Jack: How are you here right now?
Dad: How are YOU here?
Jack: I died, too. (crying)
Dad: That's OK, son ... Everything that's ever happened to you is real. All those people in the church, they're all real, too.
Dad: That's OK, son ... Everything that's ever happened to you is real. All those people in the church, they're all real, too.
Jack: They're all dead?
Dad: Everyone dies sometime, kiddo.
By the end, LOST privileges the experiences and relationships that their characters endure together. It becomes the lasting impression of what they take from the island and suggests we do the same. No matter when, where, or how these moments happen, they are the only things that we can ever know are real. It is the journey and not the destination that is important.

No comments:
Post a Comment